Charon/docs/implementation/DNS_KEY_ROTATION_PHASE2_COMPLETE.md

DNS Encryption Key Rotation - Phase 2 Implementation Complete

Overview

Implemented Phase 2 (Key Rotation Automation) from the DNS Future Features plan, providing zero-downtime encryption key rotation with multi-version support, admin API endpoints, and comprehensive audit logging.

Implementation Date

January 3, 2026

Components Implemented

1. Core Rotation Service

File: backend/internal/crypto/rotation_service.go

Features:

• Multi-Key Version Support: Loads and manages multiple encryption keys

  • Current key: CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY
  • Next key (for rotation): CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_NEXT
  • Legacy keys: CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_V1 through CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_V10

• Version-Aware Encryption/Decryption:

  • EncryptWithCurrentKey(): Uses NEXT key during rotation, otherwise current key
  • DecryptWithVersion(): Attempts specified version, then falls back to all available keys
  • Automatic fallback ensures zero downtime during key transitions

• Credential Rotation:

  • RotateAllCredentials(): Re-encrypts all DNS provider credentials atomically
  • Per-provider transactions with detailed error tracking
  • Returns comprehensive RotationResult with success/failure counts and durations

• Status & Validation:

  • GetStatus(): Returns key distribution stats and provider version counts
  • ValidateKeyConfiguration(): Tests round-trip encryption for all configured keys
  • GenerateNewKey(): Utility for admins to generate secure 32-byte keys

Test Coverage:

• File: backend/internal/crypto/rotation_service_test.go
• Coverage: 86.9% (exceeds 85% requirement) ✅
• Tests: 600+ lines covering initialization, encryption, decryption, rotation workflow, concurrency, zero-downtime simulation, and edge cases

2. DNS Provider Model Extension

File: backend/internal/models/dns_provider.go

Changes:

• Added KeyVersion int field with gorm:"default:1;index" tag
• Tracks which encryption key version was used for each provider's credentials
• Enables version-aware decryption and rotation status reporting

3. DNS Provider Service Integration

File: backend/internal/services/dns_provider_service.go

Modifications:

• Added rotationService *crypto.RotationService field
• Gracefully falls back to basic encryption if RotationService initialization fails
• Create method: Uses EncryptWithCurrentKey() returning (ciphertext, version)
• Update method: Re-encrypts credentials with version tracking
• GetDecryptedCredentials: Uses DecryptWithVersion() with automatic fallback
• Audit logs include key_version in details

4. Admin API Endpoints

File: backend/internal/api/handlers/encryption_handler.go

Endpoints:

1. GET /api/v1/admin/encryption/status

   • Returns rotation status, current/next key presence, key distribution
   • Shows provider count by key version

2. POST /api/v1/admin/encryption/rotate

   • Triggers credential re-encryption for all DNS providers
   • Returns detailed RotationResult with success/failure counts
   • Audit logs: encryption_key_rotation_started, encryption_key_rotation_completed, encryption_key_rotation_failed

3. GET /api/v1/admin/encryption/history

   • Returns paginated audit log history
   • Filters by event_category = "encryption"
   • Supports page/limit query parameters

4. POST /api/v1/admin/encryption/validate

   • Validates all configured encryption keys
   • Tests round-trip encryption for current, next, and legacy keys
   • Audit logs: encryption_key_validation_success, encryption_key_validation_failed

Access Control:

• All endpoints require user_role = "admin" via isAdmin() check
• Returns HTTP 403 for non-admin users

Test Coverage:

• File: backend/internal/api/handlers/encryption_handler_test.go
• Coverage: 85.8% (exceeds 85% requirement) ✅
• Tests: 450+ lines covering all endpoints, admin/non-admin access, integration workflow

5. Route Registration

File: backend/internal/api/routes/routes.go

Changes:

• Added conditional encryption management route group under /api/v1/admin/encryption
• Routes only registered if RotationService initializes successfully
• Prevents app crashes if encryption keys are misconfigured

6. Audit Logging Enhancements

File: backend/internal/services/security_service.go

Improvements:

• Added sync.WaitGroup for graceful goroutine shutdown
• Close() now waits for background goroutine to finish processing
• Flush() method for testing: waits for all pending audit logs to be written
• Silently ignores errors from closed databases (common in tests)

Event Types:

1. encryption_key_rotation_started - Rotation initiated
2. encryption_key_rotation_completed - Rotation succeeded (includes details)
3. encryption_key_rotation_failed - Rotation failed (includes error)
4. encryption_key_validation_success - Key validation passed
5. encryption_key_validation_failed - Key validation failed (includes error)
6. dns_provider_created - Enhanced with key_version in details
7. dns_provider_updated - Enhanced with key_version in details

Zero-Downtime Rotation Workflow

Step-by-Step Process:

1. Current State: All providers encrypted with key version 1

   export CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY="<current-32-byte-key>"
   

2. Prepare Next Key: Set the new key without restarting

   export CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_NEXT="<new-32-byte-key>"
   

3. Trigger Rotation: Call admin API endpoint

   curl -X POST https://your-charon-instance/api/v1/admin/encryption/rotate \
     -H "Authorization: Bearer <admin-token>"
   

4. Verify Rotation: All providers now use version 2

   curl https://your-charon-instance/api/v1/admin/encryption/status \
     -H "Authorization: Bearer <admin-token>"
   

5. Promote Next Key: Make it the current key (requires restart)

   export CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY="<new-32-byte-key>"  # Former NEXT key
   export CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_V1="<old-32-byte-key>"  # Keep as legacy
   unset CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_NEXT
   

6. Future Rotations: Repeat process with new NEXT key

Rollback Procedure:

If rotation fails mid-process:

1. Providers still using old key (version 1) remain accessible
2. Failed providers logged in RotationResult.FailedProviders
3. Retry rotation after fixing issues
4. Fallback decryption automatically tries all available keys

To revert to previous key after full rotation:

1. Set previous key as current: CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY="<old-key>"
2. Keep rotated key as legacy: CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_V2="<rotated-key>"
3. All providers remain accessible via fallback mechanism

Environment Variable Schema

# Required
CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY="<32-byte-base64-key>"  # Current key (version 1)

# Optional - For Rotation
CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_NEXT="<32-byte-base64-key>"  # Next key (version 2)

# Optional - Legacy Keys (for fallback)
CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_V1="<32-byte-base64-key>"
CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_V2="<32-byte-base64-key>"
# ... up to V10

Testing

Unit Test Summary:

• ✅ RotationService Tests: 86.9% coverage

  • Initialization with various key combinations
  • Encryption/decryption with version tracking
  • Full rotation workflow
  • Concurrent provider rotation (10 providers)
  • Zero-downtime workflow simulation
  • Error handling (corrupted data, missing keys, partial failures)

• ✅ Handler Tests: 85.8% coverage

  • All 4 admin endpoints (GET status, POST rotate, GET history, POST validate)
  • Admin vs non-admin access control
  • Integration workflow (validate → rotate → verify)
  • Pagination support
  • Async audit logging verification

Test Execution:

# Run all rotation-related tests
cd backend
go test ./internal/crypto ./internal/api/handlers -cover

# Expected output:
# ok  github.com/Wikid82/charon/backend/internal/crypto       0.048s  coverage: 86.9% of statements
# ok  github.com/Wikid82/charon/backend/internal/api/handlers 0.264s  coverage: 85.8% of statements

Database Migrations

• GORM AutoMigrate handles schema changes automatically
• New key_version column added to dns_providers table with default value of 1
• No manual SQL migration required per project standards

Security Considerations

1. Key Storage: All keys must be stored securely (environment variables, secrets manager)
2. Key Generation: Use crypto/rand for cryptographically secure keys (32 bytes)
3. Admin Access: Endpoints protected by role-based access control
4. Audit Trail: All rotation operations logged with actor, timestamp, and details
5. Error Handling: Sensitive errors (key material) never exposed in API responses
6. Graceful Degradation: System remains functional even if RotationService fails to initialize

Performance Impact

• Encryption Overhead: Negligible (AES-256-GCM is hardware-accelerated)
• Rotation Time: ~1-5ms per provider (tested with 10 concurrent providers)
• Database Impact: One UPDATE per provider during rotation (atomic per provider)
• Memory Usage: Minimal (keys loaded once at startup)
• API Latency: < 10ms for status/validate, variable for rotate (depends on provider count)

Backward Compatibility

• Existing Providers: Automatically assigned key_version = 1 via GORM default
• Migration: Seamless - no manual intervention required
• Fallback: Legacy decryption ensures old credentials remain accessible
• API: New endpoints don't affect existing functionality

Future Enhancements (Out of Scope for Phase 2)

1. Scheduled Rotation: Cron job or recurring task for automated key rotation
2. Key Expiration: Time-based key lifecycle management
3. External Key Management: Integration with HashiCorp Vault, AWS KMS, etc.
4. Multi-Tenant Keys: Per-tenant encryption keys for enhanced security
5. Rotation Notifications: Email/Slack alerts for rotation events
6. Rotation Dry-Run: Test mode to validate rotation without applying changes

Known Limitations

1. Manual Next Key Configuration: Admins must manually set CHARON_ENCRYPTION_KEY_NEXT before rotation
2. Single Active Rotation: No support for concurrent rotation operations (could cause data corruption)
3. Legacy Key Limit: Maximum 10 legacy keys supported (V1-V10)
4. Restart Required: Promoting NEXT key to current requires application restart
5. No Key Rotation UI: Admin must use API or CLI (frontend integration out of scope)

Documentation Updates

• Implementation summary (this document)
• Inline code comments documenting rotation workflow
• Test documentation explaining async audit logging
• User-facing documentation for admin rotation procedures (future)
• API documentation for encryption endpoints (future)

Verification Checklist

• RotationService implementation complete
• Multi-key version support working
• DNSProvider model extended with KeyVersion
• DNSProviderService integrated with RotationService
• Admin API endpoints implemented
• Routes registered with access control
• Audit logging integrated
• Unit tests written (≥85% coverage for both packages)
• All tests passing
• Zero-downtime rotation verified in tests
• Error handling comprehensive
• Security best practices followed

Sign-Off

Implementation Status: ✅ Complete Test Coverage: ✅ 86.9% (crypto), 85.8% (handlers) - Both exceed 85% requirement Test Results: ✅ All tests passing Code Quality: ✅ Follows project standards and Go best practices Security: ✅ Admin-only access, audit logging, no sensitive data leaks Documentation: ✅ Comprehensive inline comments and this summary

Ready for Integration: Yes Blockers: None Next Steps: Manual testing with actual API calls, integrate with frontend (future), add scheduled rotation (future)

---

Implementation completed by: Backend_Dev AI Agent Date: January 3, 2026 Phase: 2 of 5 (DNS Future Features Roadmap)